A Janitor’s Misclassification Results in Labor Commissioner Award

On April 13, 2015, the Labor Commissioner awarded Center for Workers’ Rights client Juana Rangel $27,053.14 in wages and penalties as a result of her misclassification as an independent contractor.  Ms. Rangel was employed as a janitor by Property Maintenance Group. Her work shift was from 5pm until 4am and she worked every day, except Sunday.


Ms. Rangel was paid cash on a bi-weekly basis. The Hearing Officer determined that the employer’s “classification of Plaintiff as an independent contractor was nothing more than a subterfuge to avoid its obligations as an employer.” The Hearing Officer held, therefore, that the employer was not credible and that Ms. Rangel’s testimony was sufficient to establish her work hours.


Law student Cecilia Guevara-Zamora represented Ms. Rangel at the hearing.  The Center for Workers’ Rights is working with Los Angeles-based Wage Justice Center  in order to ensure full recovery of the wages and penalties awarded.

Latest News

Worker Wins Against EDD’s Unlawful Redetermination

CWR continues to hear from workers that are fighting to maintain unemployment benefits paid to them during the pandemic unemployment benefits programs, which expired more than two years ago. Most recently, CWR supported a leasing consultant in her second hearing...

Paid Sick Leave Increase for Workers in 2024

All employees have the right to Paid Sick Leave in California and on January 1, 2024 the amount of time an employee can take will increase.  Since 2015, California full-time and part-time workers at employers of any size have had the right to take a minimum of 3 paid...

Know Your Rights Training at the Union Job Fair

On October 11, 2023,  the Center for Workers Rights joined numerous Unionized employers  for the South Sacramento Union Job Fair hosted by the Sacramento Central Labor Council. The event provided opportunities for community members to receive information about...

Share This